New review on CPPS & IC by Anthony Schaeffer

Latest research and happenings
kevin
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 458
Joined: Tue Aug 03, 2004 2:23 am
Location: USA

New review on CPPS & IC by Anthony Schaeffer

Post by kevin »

Here's are some quotes from a recent review article by Anthony Schaeffer of U Chicago on CPPS/IC. He's a well-known clinician who wrote a 2006 review on CPPS in the New England Journal of Medicine.
Genitourinary pain syndromes, prostatitis, and lower urinary tract symptoms.

Le BV, Schaeffer AJ.

Department of Urology, Northwestern University, Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, IL, USA.

The overlap of pain and urinary voiding symptoms is common for urologic patients. The etiology of these syndromes is frequently multifactorial and due to disorders of the bladder and/or prostate. The evaluation and treatment of these syndromes continues to evolve. Here we summarize the general approach to evaluation and treatment of these pain syndromes.
There are no formal guidelines for the management of CPPS and no proven therapies.Though category III prostatitis has been broken down into inflammatory (IIIa) and noninflammatory (IIIb) prostatitis based on the presence or absence of leukocytes in expressed prostatic fluid, this has not proven to be of much clinical utility. Numerous trials have failed to demonstrate efficacy of antimicrobials, alpha-blockers, anti-inflammatories, phytotherapy, biofeedback, thermal therapies, and pelvic floor training. A recently completed multicenter, randomized, double-blinded, placebo-controlled trial looking at alfuzosin for the treatment of chronic prostatitis–pelvic pain syndrome showed no benefit over placebo.

If a patient has significant LUTS, goal-directed therapy should be considered and alpha-blockers may offer some benefit. Pelvic floor physical therapy may also be beneficial. Newer classes of medications, such as pregabalin used in the treatment of fibromyalgia and postherpetic neuralgia, show some promising preliminary data in this population as well.
After discussing IC and CPPS, he has a section on what he calls "pelvic floor pain syndrome".
Pelvic floor pain syndrome
Pelvic floor pain syndrome (PFPS) goes by many different names including levator ani syndrome and pelvic floor dysfunction, though it should not be confused with laxity of the pelvic floor in women. It is a condition characterized by pelvic/anorectal pain arising from spasm of the pelvic floor muscles. There is significant overlap between this condition, CPPS (category III prostatitis), and interstitial cystitis. As many as 50% of patients with CPPS report myofascial pain with palpation. Up to 87% of women with a diagnosis of interstitial cystitis may demonstrate symptoms consistent with PFPS. Though PFPS has been recognized to contribute to many of the above conditions and can exacerbate LUTS, treatment and research into this condition as a separate clinical entity have been limited. Evaluation consists of a history, genitourinary physical, urinalysis, and urine culture. The most notable findings on examination are myofascial trigger points, which are defined by Simons and colleagues as tender spots created by injury at the motor end plate as a result of acute, repetitive, or sustained muscle overloading. Muscles of the pelvis must be examined carefully, with each muscle palpated separately, to gain some idea about their tenderness or spasm. Diagnosis is made based on positive examination findings with or without urinary symptoms.

Treatment of PFPS consists of combination of biofeedback exercises, physical therapy, and pain medications. No randomized controlled trials on PFPS have been conducted, but response rates with the combinations described above have noted response rates of 32% noting marked improvement and another 30% having modest improvement in symptoms.
Started: Spring 2003; high urinary frequency and pain associated with bladder filling; urinary hesitancy; pubic/prostate/perineal discomfort; Helped by: trigger point therapy, Afrin nasal spray, Cymbalta, hydrocodone (small doses), distraction. Makes worse: sex.

Not medical advice. Consult your doctor.
User avatar
webslave
Maintenance
Maintenance
Posts: 11432
Joined: Wed Oct 30, 2002 3:18 pm
Location: Please give your location so we can help better

Re: New review on CPPS & IC by Anthony Schaeffer

Post by webslave »

I mean no disrespect to Dr Schaeffer, now around 70 yrs old, but a recent overview of prostatitis he wrote for "Knol" concentrated on alpha blockers as the mainstay of treatment and gave Bradley Hennenfent's book as recommended reading.

I'll quote a review of Schaeffer's overview that points out some of the oversights and errors he makes:
Errors such as saying pollen extracts don't help (there are at least two studies proving that cernilton does help).

Errors such as saying immunosuppression (cortisosteroids) cannot help (see PMID 10840443).

Errors such as stating that muscle relaxants are not useful (which study proved that?)

Too many mentions of bacteria and infection, even under the Category III section (I guess this is to be expected from an older urologist, set in his ideas).

Also too "prostatocentric" — CPPS is not a prostate condition.

Very disturbing to see that there is a link to the Hennenfent book that claims all prostatitis— including Category III (CP/CPPS)—is bacterial. This is complete nonsense and disproved. And where is the link to the new books, like the one by Drs Anderson and Wise (Headache in the Pelvis)?
I notice that Schaeffer included a link to Headache in the Pelvis after seeing this comment.
Good News! The great ProstaQ is BACK at last! You must try it.

HAS THIS SITE HELPED YOU?
Say Thanks by donating. Keep the
Forum alive on the Internet!
PayPal link at end of page ↓

Contact me at support at ucpps.men